Passé composé (avoir): participle agrees when the COD is before the verb
The Passé Composé — Agreement with Avoir (COD Before the Verb)
In French, past participle agreement with Avoir is possible and is a common source of confusion.
The key is that agreement only happens under a very specific condition.
The Big Idea: Agreement with Avoir
- With Avoir, the past participle does not agree with the subject.
- Instead, it agrees with the direct object (COD) only if the COD comes before the verb.
Examples
| French | English | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| J’ai mangé la pomme. | I ate the apple. | COD “la pomme” comes after → no agreement |
| La pomme que j’ai mangée. | The apple that I ate. | COD “que” comes before → agreement with “la pomme” (feminine singular) |
| Je l’ai mangée. | I ate it. | COD “l’” comes before → agreement (feminine singular) |
How to Spot It Quickly
-
Identify the direct object (COD).
-
Ask: Is the COD before the auxiliary?
- Yes → make the past participle agree with the COD.
- No → no agreement.
Key Points
- Past participle with Avoir = usually invariable.
- Agreement happens only if COD is placed before the verb.
- Agreement is with the COD, not the subject.
Important Note 1
Not sure if a past participle ends with s, t, or nothing? Use the Feminine Trick: imagine the word in its feminine form to "hear" the hidden consonant.
- Prendre (to take) → Is it prise? Yes! → ends in s (pris).
- Écrire (to write) → Is it écrite? Yes! → ends in t (écrit).
- Vendre (to sell) → Is it vendue? Yes! → ends in u (vendu).
Important Note 2
With Avoir, you only agree with the Direct Object (COD) if it is placed BEFORE the verb.
- No Agreement: J'ai mangé les pommes. (The apples are after the verb).
- Agreement: Les pommes que j'ai mangées. (The apples are before the verb).
Key Takeaways
-
Regular rule: Avoir → no agreement with the subject
-
Exception: COD before the verb → agree with COD
-
Examples:
- J’ai mangé la pomme → no agreement
- La pomme que j’ai mangée → agree (feminine singular)
- Je l’ai mangée → agree (feminine singular)
In the app, you will find interactive exercises and quizzes tailored for this intermediate level.
Practice French conjugation for free in the Croissant Verbs app
Quizzes and spaced repetition for every tense, for free on your phone—plus short grammar guides on our Learn hub.
